Hearthstone Coffee House & Pub Menu

Hearthstone Coffee House & PubHearthstone Coffee House & Pub just opened up here in Fishers, Indiana. The idea is simple… coffee, beer, food, and supporting the local community. This place has a solid foundation, and money isn’t their incentive. I have heard the general manager say, “We aren’t in this to make money.” Of course making money would be nice… but they have bigger goals here. To prove that, they are donating 10 cents from every drink to charity. That adds up fast, so drink up! I just find it so unique that a place would open, and start off by donating so much to charity. I will soon be sitting down with the general manager, and we will discuss more about that when the time is right.

The general manager is Devin Rose. I first met Devin a few weeks ago (we actually talked on the phone first) and will be writing a series of blogs about the place. I will be talking about the food, the drinks, and more. First off, I wanted to talk about the menu. As I said, in future blogs I will look at their impressive beer list, their wine list, coffee drinks, and more. I am impressed with this place after having only been here a few times. I told Devin that Hearthstone would soon become my new hangout… and I am already scheduling meetings there!


Not sure the hours here… it’s not on the menu. But they do offer a pretty good breakfast menu. I guess it makes sense that a place offering your morning cup of coffee would offer a decent selection in the morning.

Muffins – $2.49
Banana Nut, Blueberry Streusel, Cherry Cheese, Double Chocolate-Chip, or Lemon Poppy Seed.

Breakfast Ciabatta Sandwich – $2.99
Maple Sausage, Egg, and Cheddar or Bacon, Egg and Cheddar or Egg White with Spinach, Tomato and Swiss.

Scones – $2.49
Cinnamon or Blueberry.

Yogurt Parfait – $2.99
Vanilla Yogurt, Berries, and Granola.

Bagels – $2.49
Plain, Everything, Blueberry, or Cinnamon-Raisin.

Oatmeal – $2.49
Add your choice of Butter, Brown Sugar, Dried Cranberries, Pecans, Walnuts, or Granola.

Coffee Cake (Indy Desserts) – $2.49
Lemon Cranberry or Sour Cream

Fruit Cup – $1.99

Kids Fare – $2.49
Cereal and Milk, Fruit Cup, Peanut Butter and Jelly (or honey), or Mac & Cheese (Includes Entrée + Milk or Juice + Apple Slices or Applesauce + Teddy Grahams.)

As you can see, there are a lot of items on the breakfast menu. You can’t help but compare a coffee house to Starbucks… but their prices are a lot lower than Starbucks. Let’s take a look at the lunch menu.


Pick 2 – $6.99
Select two of the following: cup of soup, ½ a salad, or ½ a sandwich.

Garden Salad – $4.99
Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Sliced Peppers, Cheddar Cheese, and Croutons.

Cranberry Walnut Salad – $6.99
Grilled Chicken Breast on Mixed Greens Topped with Cranberries, Walnuts, and Blue Cheese Crumbles.

Smoked Turkey Club Salad – $6.99
Smoked Turkey Breast on Leaf Lettuce with Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Tomatoes, and Croutons.

Grilled Chicken Salad – $6.99
Grilled Chicken on Leaf Lettuce, with Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Mild Pepper Rings, Fresh Parmesan Cheese, and Croutons.

Soup (changes daily)

  • Cup (8 ounces) – $2.99
  • Bowl (12 ounces) – $4.99

Caprese Salad Sandwich – $4.99
Garden Fresh Lettuce, Tomato, Basil, and Mozzarella Cheese with Balsamic Vinaigrette on a Ciabatta. Comes with a side of kettle chips and a dill pickle spear.

Cranberry Chicken Salad Sandwich – $6.99
Chicken Salad, Lettuce, Tomato, on Cranberry Walnut Bread. Comes with a side of kettle chips and a dill pickle spear.

Smoked Turkey Club Sandwich – $6.99
Smokey Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Bacon, Tomato, Lettuce, and Sun-Dried Tomato Sauce on Whole Wheat. Comes with kettle chips and a dill pickle spear.

Grilled Chicken Sandwich – $6.99
Grilled Chicken Breast with Lettuce, Tomato, Cheddar Cheese, and Chipotle Honey Mayonnaise on Ciabatta. Comes with a side of kettle chips and a dill pickle spear.

Salad dressings include Ranch, Honey Mustard, Pear Gorgonzola, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Mango Chardonnay, or Tomato Bacon.

The lunch menu is pretty impressive. Nothing on the menu is over $7 and most come with a side of kettle chips and a pickle spear. The Pick 2 reminds me of Panera Bread… but cheaper! Moving on to the dinner menu… They don’t have a dinner menu here at Hearthstone Coffee House & Pub, but they do offer some filling appetizers. I have tried a few of them and this place just opened! Let’s take a closer look at their list of appetizers.


Cellerman’s Plate – $12.99 / Half Order $7.99
Toscana Salami, Prosciutto, Aged Irish Cheddar, Marinated Olives, Bourbon Beer Cheese, Tart Apples, Garlic Sourdough, and Flatbread Crackers.

Blue Cheese & Honey – $6.99
A Wedge of Maytag Blue Cheese drizzled with Sweet Clover Honey topped with Pecans served with Flatbread Crackers.

Sweet Habanera Salsa & Chips – $6.99
A Generous Portion of our very own Sweet Habanera Salsa served with Whole Grain Blue Corn Tortilla Chips.

Fruit & Cheese Plate – $12.99 / Half Order $7.99
Fresh Sliced Apples, Grapes, and Strawberries with “Heavenly Fluff” Fruit Dip and Aged Irish Cheddar served with Flatbread Crackers and Garlic Sourdough Bread.

Veggie & Cheese Plate – $10.99 / Half Order $6.99
Sliced Peppers, Asparagus, Baby Carrots, Aged Irish Cheddar, Veggie Dip, Marinated Olives, Bourbon Beer Cheese, and Flatbread Crackers.

Bourbon Beer Cheese – $6.99
A Hearthstone Classic Spread made with Aged White Cheddar and Parmesan cheeses, People’s Amber Ale and Bourbon. Served with Flatbread Crackers.

Hummus & Pita Chips – $6.99
Roasted Red Pepper Hummus Served with Baked Pita Bread. Add a side of fresh veggies $1.99.

The Cellerman’s Plate rocks. It reminds me of a dish I have had at Bella Vita once. The only thing that would make this dish better is a side of asparagus. Nothing beats wrapping fresh prosciutto around a stick of asparagus. The bourbon beer cheese is pretty good too. Oh, and the “fluff” fruit dip rocks! The apps will be a nice touch when they have tastings… like wine and martini tastings. They will be doing those every month.

You can’t have a coffee shop and not have a list of desserts to choose from. Starbucks has cake pops… but Hearthstone has brownies, cakes, and cookies. Let’s take a closer look at their dessert menu.


Brownies – $1.99
Brownie and Blondie flavors are available.

Cake – $3.99
Choose from Carrot Cake, German Chocolate Cake, or Amaretto Cheese.

Premium Desserts – $4.99
Choose from Tiramisu, Lemon Sunshine, Chocolate Decadence, Strawberry Surprise, or Mascarpone.

Coffee Cake – $2.49
Choose from Lemon Cranberry or Sour Cream.

Cupcakes (Provided by Flying Cupcakes) – $3.49
3 Flavors available daily.

Cookies (Provided by Flying Cupcake) – $2.49 / Half $1.49
3 Flavors available daily.

Last week, I had the chance to try a few of these desserts. First up was the coffee cake. It was a little dry, but that’s what makes coffee cake so good. It really does taste better with a cup of coffee. The crust is my favorite part. I also tried one of the cupcakes and the tiramisu. I must say, it was the weirdest looking tiramisu I have ever seen… but it was incredible. It was cold, which I usually don’t care for. But the way this one was presented made all the difference. Any one of these would go good with the South American. Imagine this… coffee, chocolate, and Patron XO. Oh man… it’s amazing! It’s the best coffee drink I have ever had. Not sure of the calorie count, but it’s incredible.

If you are hungry, and looking for a new place to hang out on Indy’s north side, stop by Hearthstone Coffee & Pub. They have an impressive beer list, some incredible coffee flavors, and a nice atmosphere. I have a feeling I will be spending a ton of time here.

Have you been to Hearthstone Coffee House & Pub? What is your favorite thing on the menu?

Click here to “like” Hearthstone Coffee House & Pub on Facebook.

Click here to follow Hearthstone Coffee House & Pub on Twitter.